Frequently Asked Questions

Why do we need a new method of locating the presence of whales?   top

Our goal is to protect whales from ship collisions and the acoustic effects of man-made activities that can endanger whales. Federal regulations are in place, or are being drafted, that require these activities to be suspended if whales are detected in the vicinity. However, the two current methods of detecting the presence of whales – visual identification and passive sonar -- are inadequate. Visual identification does not work at night or when weather and sea conditions are inclement. Passive sonar does not work during those frequent periods when whales are silent.

How many whales are injured, killed, or significantly harassed annually by ship collisions or man-made acoustical events?  top

Numbers are not known because it is impossible to observe all the whales in the vicinity of a potentially harmful activity (which is precisely the problem we are trying to solve).  However, there is evidence that a large number of whales are impacted every year. Our goal is to reduce these numbers by developing a safe way of detecting the presence of whales under any conditions.

What are dangerous man-made acoustic events?  top

Whales use their hearing for navigating the world’s oceans, for communicating with each other, and for identifying the presence of food sources and predators. Some loud activities can damage whales’ hearing, just as standing too close to a rock concert amplifier can injure human hearing. Dangerous acoustic events can occur during seismic exploration, demolition, and submarine detection. Our goal is to protect whales from the acoustic effects of these activities by developing a safe way of detecting the presence of whales under any conditions.

How does the new method work?  top

Our approach turns sound to our advantage. It uses low-power and high-frequency active sonar soundings to detect the presence of whales when they are silent, and regardless of weather or sea conditions. This is important knowledge. If we know whales are near, we can be more vigilant in navigation and can stop potentially dangerous activities until the whales pass to safety.

How does active sonar differ from passive sonar?  top

Passive sonar, as the name implies, involves listening only. It only works when whales are vocalizing, and that simply is not frequently enough to protect whale populations. Active sonar, by contrast, emits a sound wave and then listens for the sound to bounce back.

What is the difference between the sound that you are using and dangerous sound?  top

Not all sound is the same. The new proposed method for protecting whales uses active sonar at low power levels and at high frequencies. There is strong scientific evidence that the selected frequency is beyond the hearing range of most whales.  However, even if they could hear the sound there is strong scientific evidence that it would not be loud enough to cause any damage to their hearing.  The transmitted sound is also much shorter than whale vocalizations, and would sound like is a small click roughly every four seconds.

What are the risks to whales?  top

We have worked closely with leading marine mammal experts to understand safe acoustic limits that are accepted by the scientific community. There is strong scientific evidence that the selected frequency under research is beyond the hearing range of most whales. However, we are taking no chances since science is about learning and building upon established knowledge. To further protect the safety of the whales, marine mammal experts participating in every facet of the research will have the authority to suspend testing if they observe abnormal behavior. Our goal is to protect whales, so it makes no sense to continue any research that causes abnormal behavior.

What are examples of abnormal behavior that would cause the research to be suspended?  top

  The whales migrate from north to south and generally continue on that path. An anomalous rapid turn or sudden breaching would be the most likely signs of stress.

 

Copyrights Scientific Solutions, Inc. © All rights reserved
All photographs © David M. Barron/Oxygengroup